Search This Blog

Sunday 30 December 2012

The Right Punishment for a Rapist...


As women living in India, how many of us can say they have never felt scared being out after the dark, or even during the day (depending on which part of the country we live in)? Walking the roads in India for women was never safe, and it still is not. If anything, it has only become worse. Women earlier were used to being whistled at, hearing the lewd comments being passed, teased and so on and so forth. We were taught to mind our ways, ignore such men, and be back home before sunset. Now, with so much ‘progress’ that our country has supposedly made, the eve-teasers, as they have always been called, too have graduated to become rapists? The North, in particular has been in the news again and again in the past few months for rapes- nothing was done except giving sympathy and monetary compensation to the victim’s family (at best!!!).

Unless lawmakers think it through, and make tougher laws to deal with use and abuse of the laws, the loop-holes, the implementation and the corrupt system that engulfs it all….we will just feel sorry for the victims, and hope we do not have to go through that pain at personal level.

What is the right punishment anyway for a rapist? Should he  (/they) be hanged to death publicly, ostracized from the community, castrated (as most of the women feel), beaten and shamed publicly, or should we just tell ourselves that we cannot stoop to their level and let them just serve a few years in prison? What can be done with the current rotten state of India’s legal, political and administrative system? The truth is, a rapist or his family can never understand the victim’s pain, the emotional scarring, and the mental trauma. A rapist deserves to feel that pain, to wallow in the same sadness, to feel the burning sensation of an unwanted touch, to acknowledge that what he did was utterly and absolutely wrong…

What is the best way then to  teach him a lesson, to punish him so anyone even tempted to rape thinks thrice before putting his temptation before him….????
Is there a way to change mentality really?
Can we make the men on those streets, public spaces and offices and everywhere else respect women if they have not learnt it in their own families and surroundings?
We need to redo the emotional wiring of these men I think…if there is way to do it.

2 comments:

  1. I want to say that the latest thinking I hear about rape is:

    It is a crime of violence - with sex being the weapon.

    Castration does not stop the rapist from doing violence.

    It is very common here. I have not been raped but I know many women who have been. I know two women who have been raped twice - by different men. And one poor woman who was gang-raped by six men.

    Some researchers believe that people are born pedophiles, almost lacking choice. Almost.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Catty,

      Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Interesting thought, i must say, but i still believe that the offender should be punished. Being a man should not be his excuse nor should it allow him to get away with being violent, whatever weapon he chooses to use. We can't change their minds, but we can definitely lobby to punish them for their crimes...In any case, all men are definitely not like that. take care...

      Delete

These observations are my point of view of the life, as I see it. This blog does not intend to hurt, rationalise, judge, ridicule, or in any way offend anyone at all...it is only a way of sharing my own observations...so, please take it in the right spirit....thanks.